Let the best blog win, irrespective of its popularity
We started with seeing only those Indian blogs that are either personal or run by small groups or NGOs in a collaborative spirit rather than commercial activity. After some discussion, we excluded blogs that needed registration and collaborative blogs on non-Indian affairs in which some members were Indian.
There were too many blogs on IT, gadgets, hacking etc and we had to discard majority of them in favour of those where the blogger had made special personal contribution rather than aggregating material from other sites. Some IT and news blogs had too much automated content and too little personal effort by our reckoning. We also had to exclude niche blogs, such as those on pure science, medical specialities and software codes. We have also not included non-English blogs, because we are not proficient in many Indian languages.
Of the blogs we did not exclude this way, we looked for regularity of posting. Blogs not regularly updated and whose posting was less than once a month consistently were rejected. We had to reject many beautiful, high quality blogs but we could not help that. Of the blogs so shortlisted, we looked first at the quality of content. This included the text, its presentation, language, grammar, use of graphics, etc. Then came the design elements including readability and length of posts.
To reduce subjectivity, all of us four gave marks to each of the shortlisted blogs [978 in all] on these parameters and came down to about a hundred top blogs. We sat together to have a final look at the blogs and reduced the list to 32 and gave ranks to these blogs based on a fair mix of marks given by individual members on different parameters. We are still not sure whether we should have given a higher or lower ranking than what we have given to some of these blogs.
As it was the first such exercise by us, and because we realised that we must have missed thousands of top quality blogs and made errors of judgement in various parameters, we have deliberately not given Diamond and Platinum rankings this time. As such, our rankings are limited to bringing to the fore very good quality blogs, generally personal blogs in which bloggers have invested good amount of time, energy, thought and imagination.
At the end of this exercise, we find that individual bloggers with zeal for presenting their worldview in an interesting way do ignore certain essentials of blogging. Based on our collective understanding and experience of blogging as well as what we learnt during this exercise, the Indian Top Blogs will soon come out with posts to help individual bloggers in sprucing up their blogs.